Urban Elevators and the Geography of Labor Market Polarization
June 22, 2026
Summary
Using longitudinal French administrative data, the authors document that employment polarization after 1994 reflects major changes in labor-market entry rather than mass occupational downgrading or displacement of incumbent workers.
View PaperWorking Paper 2026-7a (Revised November 2026)
Formerly titled: The Anatomy of Polarization: Evidence from Worker Flows
Abstract: Large cities gain abstract jobs and shed routine jobs faster than small ones. Whether this divergence arises because workers move across locations or because workers' labor market careers differ across locations matters for welfare and policy, and cross-sectional data cannot tell the two apart. Using the French administrative panel DADS–EDP (1984–2021), we decompose the change in each occupation's employment share, by city size, into within-city occupational switches, cross-city relocation, combined moves, and non-employment flows. The divergence is produced inside cities. We find that large cities move workers from routine to abstract jobs at twice the rate of small cities, and this flow more than accounts for the urban gap in abstract employment. The routine decline is absorbed by upgrading into abstract work, not by downgrading into manual services. This urban elevator predates the 1994 onset of French polarization and operates within occupations: holding worker characteristics and the occupation of origin fixed, staying in a large city raises the rate of upgrading by about 40 percent, for college and non-college workers alike. The evidence places the burden of explanation on agglomeration forces that act on occupational mobility within cities rather than on the sorting of heterogeneous workers across them.
JEL classification: J62, J24, J21
Key words: labor market polarization; worker flows; occupational mobility; routine-biased technological change; longitudinal data
https://doi.org/10.29338/wp2026-07
The authors thank seminar participants in Aix-en-Provence and Cagliari for helpful comments and Simone Nobili for valuable research support in the early stages of this project. Cerina, Dienesch and Moro acknowledge financial support from the European Union–NextGenerationEU and the Italian Ministry of University and Research, PRIN PNRR Project No. P2022KHP8L, CUP F53D23009430001 and the Regional Government of Sardinia—Fondazione di Sardegna; Monge-Naranjo financial support from the Research Council of the European University Institute. The views expressed are the authors' alone and do not reflect those of the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta or the Federal Reserve System. All errors are the authors'.
Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta working papers, including revised versions, are available on the Atlanta Fed's website at www.atlantafed.org. Click "Publications" and then "Working Papers." To receive e-mail notifications about new papers, go to subscribe.